Meta, Google and TikTok each filed a lawsuit on Wednesday, Nov. 4, against California Attorney General Rob Bonta, asking the courts to block AB 1709, a state law that bans autoplay video and personalized feeds for users under 16 [1]. The law is set to take effect Jan. 1, 2027, and the filings put one question in front of a judge before then. Does California get to order YouTube, TikTok and Facebook to switch off the features that decide which clip, song or creator a young fan sees next, or does that call stay with the platforms and with parents?

The record the suits land on is unusual. Meta agreed in August to pay up to $18 billion to settle 29 states' claims over children's safety, and that deal sets out, pending judicial approval, a 10-year slate of teen controls across Facebook and Instagram [2]. The fight, then, is over mandate. The companies are contesting a state deadline, a state fine and a state definition of an addictive feed, while under-16 accounts wait to learn whether their feeds change by state requirement on Jan. 1 or stay as the apps' own settings leave them.

What switches off for under-16 accounts on Jan. 1

Signed by Governor Gavin Newsom in September and titled "Covered platforms: age restriction" in the chaptered text, AB 1709 prohibits social platforms from offering autoplay videos and personalized feeds to users under 16, requires platforms to delete those accounts if the features stay on, and sets fines of up to $50,000 per affected user under 16 [1][3]. The bill also creates an e-Safety Advisory Commission that must report to the Legislature and the Governor every Jan. 1 on harmful design features, platform safety practices and related state rulemaking [3].

The two named features sit at the center of each app in this story. Autoplay runs one clip into the next on YouTube and TikTok, and personalized feeds decide what a user sees next, the mechanism behind TikTok's For You recommendations and the ranked feeds on Facebook and Instagram. Google says part of this is already in place on YouTube, where autoplay is turned off for minors by default [1].

Why the platforms call AB 1709 unconstitutional

All three complaints share a First Amendment spine, and each company adds a product defense of its own. Meta argues the law overrides its editorial decisions about how to display content and that Section 230 preempts it; TikTok and Google make similar arguments [1]. Meta's complaint frames the stakes for its feeds directly. "Meta currently organizes its feeds of content to include personalized content recommendations and to automatically play media, [so] the Act would make it unlawful for Meta to disseminate speech to minors altogether, and would require Meta to delete minors' accounts, unless it changes these practices" [1]. TikTok's spokesperson calls the bill "a blatantly unconstitutional restriction on free expression that erodes the long-standing and protected practice of curating content based on user preferences, which book stores, TV networks and streaming services all use" [1].

Google's statement leans on parents rather than the Constitution alone. "We believe parents are best positioned to make the right decisions for their families," a spokesperson said, adding that overly broad laws "break the systems we've built to help kids find high-quality, age-appropriate videos" [1]. The company adds that parents can switch off teens' access to Shorts altogether [1]. The Attorney General's office says it is reviewing the filings and is committed to "defending California's commonsense laws to protect kids online" [1].

Privacy advocates warn of a different cost

The law's critics outside the industry worry about what age checks cost every user. "AB 1709 compels platforms to collect even more information from every user, invading everyone's privacy and frustrating our ability to remain anonymous online," said Rindala Alajaji, the Electronic Frontier Foundation's associate director of state affairs [1]. Alajaji also calls the bill "a functional ban on social media for youth under 16" that cuts young people off from essential information, pointing to March for Our Lives and Greta Thunberg as activism that social media amplified [1].

The global record hands neither side a clean win. In December 2025, Australia became the first country to ban social media for users under 16 altogether. France passed a similar law, and its top court struck it down on free-expression grounds [1].

Meta already agreed to versions of these rules

Meta's own August settlement is the strongest evidence that such controls can exist without a mandate. TechCrunch reported the deal at up to $18 billion; Mashable put the figure at $17 billion [2][4]. Developed with 52 state attorneys general, it runs 10 years and, pending judicial approval, includes a default two-hour daily time limit across Facebook and Instagram, with usage alerts at 60 and 90 minutes and prompts every 15 minutes [2]. Night Mode blocks Meta's apps from midnight to 6 AM, notifications mute from 8 AM to 3 PM in the hours teens should be in school, and like and reaction counts stay hidden on teens' own posts and others' [2]. The list also includes a block on what Meta calls "extreme makeup filters" and investment in age assurance technology [2]. Direct messages stay outside the time limits [2]. Mashable's account of the deal adds a default non-algorithmic feed option and an autoplay opt-out [4].

Meta then asked its rivals to match the framework. "Because teens move fluidly across dozens of apps, we need an industry-wide solution," Chief Legal Officer C.J. Mahoney said, and the company published an open letter to YouTube and TikTok [2][5]. About $5.3 billion of the settlement, roughly 30 percent, pays out only if YouTube and TikTok adopt a one-hour daily limit, Night Mode and age assurance, plus a matching payment of their own [2]. Neither company joined the settlement terms [4]. Mashable's other voice is Lennon Torres, described by the site as a former child influencer who leads movement partnerships at the Heat Initiative. Torres, who also contributes to Mashable, told the outlet that the free-speech framing misses what she sees as the real stake, a business model that profits from keeping kids scrolling [4].

What can still change before Jan. 1

Two things can still change how under-16 feeds look on Jan. 1. One is the litigation itself, with Meta and Google on the Northern District of California docket and no ruling issued in the days since filing [4]. The other is judicial approval of Meta's settlement terms, which would switch on the deal's teen controls across Facebook and Instagram [2].

One earlier case is easy to mix up with these filings. In March, a Los Angeles jury found Meta and YouTube negligent in a social media safety trial, awarding $3 million in compensatory damages and $3 million in punitive damages; TikTok and Snap had settled that case before trial, and both remaining defendants are appealing [6].

The record so far adds up to a narrow conclusion. The controls AB 1709 demands already exist in some form on the biggest platforms, according to the companies' own agreements and statements. What no company has accepted is a state deadline, a state fine and a state definition of an addictive feed. A judge now holds that question, and the Jan. 1 clock is running.