Nobody told me that "See You Again, Friends" has seven comedians on it! You think only we want to hear gossip? Actually, the guests on the show are even more into gossip. Your production team picked people on purpose, didn't you? Just look at this guest lineup... This variety show, originally titled "Goodbye Friends," has finally premiered.
The good news is that the people viewers wanted to see did show up; the bad news is they each only brought half of the story—and they're all sitting in the observation room. Zhou Bichang, Su Xing, Huang Zihongfan, Huang Tingting—each seemingly came alone, but in reality, each has someone standing behind them who wasn't invited.
I still stand by my suggestion: give us seven our own separate show! And they're all playing dumb while knowing perfectly well—"We totally understand what you want to hear." Take Su Xing, no explanation needed—he's been unfriended by others and has unfriended others himself.
And everyone knows about Zhou Bichang being unilaterally deleted by a fellow industry peer—"It was after I finished participating in a show, and then he deleted me." Then there's Huang Zihongfan, who encountered someone extraordinary who deleted dozens of people in his group all at once: "He deleted all the rest of us."
This is gossip an ordinary viewer shouldn't be hearing, but we can hear it! They directly besieged Su Xing, all holding out paper and pens, just short of shouting "Who was it? Write it! Write it now!"
And of course there's the main event, Huang Tingting—one of the most requested CPs by netizens. Her coming on this show is practically a name card: at one point she says "the wonderful story of three hundred girls"—"Spending time with that many girls, there must be wonderful stories, right?
" At another point she says "the one who will forever lie in my contacts, never deleted"—"Gradually we stopped contacting each other, and then she just stayed in my contacts forever." The whole court hemmed and hawed, but everyone knows that person's name is—
"Never got first place?" "When you got second, who was ahead of you?" "Li Yitong." "When I got third, first place was Ju Jingyi." Li Yitong, Ju Jingyi—me, nine years, Tingting-san, you finally said those words!
When pressed with "Are you still in contact?", she borrowed the theory of the on-site psychology expert: "That's what the teacher said—first place and third place." "So does that mean you can't even be friends anymore?" "What the teacher said before was: the awkward position of second place—those adjacent to her in the rankings always have a competitive relationship."—But who would have thought this room was packed with second-place finishers! Suddenly everyone became reference material.
If the observation room is this entertaining, the four pairs of guests in the main show are even more remarkable. The moment Ma Tianyu and Li Na met, they couldn't wait to ask: "Who did you fall out with?" "What are you laughing at? You're—didn't you see the list? Why are you asking me?" "Let me tell you, I really didn't see the list."
Upon learning that Xu Fei was coming, they got even more excited: "You two didn't even have much of a thing, did you?" "Because a lot of things... Come on, give me a little gossip, let me hear it. How did you two fight? Did you pull each other's hair? Did you call each other up and curse each other out?"
So speechless—no wait, Li Na didn't expect this segment to come with its own host either. Changing the subject, fanning the flames like crazy, defusing awkwardness: "How are you still so good-looking? You've grown—well, a Ferrari gets old but it's still a Ferrari."
That's quite endearing, but Ma Tianyu doesn't buy it at all: "There must be some misunderstanding, right?" Watching the show is hilarious—Ma Tianyu: "Are you this direct when you speak now? You came here just to talk it out, huh?" And as soon as the new guest Qingzhi finished introducing herself, Ma Tianyu immediately fired off a question.
And the production team really knows how to play it: they have one person from each pair enter first, so the fifth person to arrive is guaranteed to be one half of a fallen-out CP—that atmosphere of anticipation mixed with dread, hesitation mixed with awkwardness, precisely hooks my interest. Everyone is extremely nervous, terrified that the next person to step out of the car will be the one they fell out with, yet they still want to watch other people's drama.
For example, when Xu Fei arrived, Li Na gasped; while Ma Tianyu, who had just been so nervous, actually started making snide remarks: "Peace and love—let me tell you, later when your someone arrives, you'd better be like this too." That's very true—you can't fake it at all.
As Xu Fei walked over step by step, the fan in Li Na's hand waved faster and faster. Xu Fei led the way with a wave, but that was it—"Oh, she said hello." "Oh." A mutual "hey babe" would have been too awkward. The two just sat far apart, full of distance, full of awkwardness.
But if you know the history of love and hate between these two, then truly: if they could ease things the moment they met, that would be a miracle.
Younger viewers may not know how popular the "Fei-Xue" CP was during that summer of the 2006 Super Girl competition. Back then on stage, Li Na, choosing between Shang Wenjie and Xu Fei, resolutely raised Xu Fei's hand—"For public and private reasons, for both emotion and reason."
Wow, "for public and private reasons, for both emotion and reason," she chose Xu Fei. That's what she said, but in reality there was no public interest, only private affection. Even now, people say these two may have practically dated: each had their own nicknames for each other, beautiful memories, choking up and crying when talking about the past, even sobbing while watching music videos. The footage was shot more "See You Again, Lover" than "See You Again, Lover," yet for over a decade they've been like enemies.
It's said that back then Li Na was approached by other companies wanting her to break her contract and switch labels. Unable to make up her mind, she discussed it with Xu Fei, whom she was close with; Xu Fei then turned around and told the company's executives, leading to nearly a decade of career lows for Li Na.
"You can distance yourself from someone like that, you can distance yourself from a friend like that." She was once so anxious she binge-ate and her weight skyrocketed. Feeling backstabbed and betrayed, Li Na unfollowed and deleted Xu Fei.
Of course, Xu Fei doesn't see it that way. Both sides stick to their own accounts. Xu Fei wanted to say that's not how it happened, but couldn't really defend herself—"This is too ridiculous. Those things aren't me, how am I supposed to explain? If I say that wasn't me, would anyone listen?"
On top of that, there was the later Super Girl reunion on "Ace vs. Ace," where Xu Fei tried to create some show moments with Li Na, plus her conversation with Shang Wenjie, which triggered another series of conflicts: "I feel I must say something on Wenjie's behalf—she was the same during the competition as she is now." I've seen that clip, I've seen it—which led to Xu Fei completely leaving the 2006 Super Girl group chat, and the two cut off all contact.
So with all these layers stacked up, if these two could immediately reconcile or reach out to each other, then Li Na's decade-plus of resentment would be a joke.
Of course, it's not like there aren't pairs who can meet and embrace with smiles—for example, Wen Ji'er and Wang Zixuan: one is a writer and the other an actress. They met during their student days when they both appeared on the show "Day Day Up." It should have been just a brief encounter, but because they were both struggling in Beijing with few friends, they gravitated toward each other—"It just felt like this person looked so familiar, like there was this inexplicable sense of familiarity."
Wen Ji'er, newly arrived in Beijing, barged into Wang Zixuan's life like a "home invasion," becoming each other's support on their respective paths of striving, and becoming a sense of ritual in each other's lives: they even met every day, traveled together, had all kinds of matching clothes and shoes, constantly refreshed each other's WeChat Moments, and had all sorts of records and proof. Because Wen Ji'er nearly drowned as a child, she was afraid of water, and Wang Zixuan would wash her hair for her—she was even said to have "healed her childhood trauma." It's fair to say that all of the two's secrets and the important moments of their lives bore each other's presence.
The preface to Wen Ji'er's book was written by Wang Zixuan—but not the only one. Before her preface, there was another one written by a friend the two shared: after Wang Zixuan's career took off, she was always away filming and worried Wen Ji'er would be lonely, so she introduced another friend of hers to Wen Ji'er—and then she started getting jealous of this third person.
"The things you two talk about, I can't seem to understand anymore. Your interactions, I can't follow them. Your rapport, I'm jealous of it.
Your closeness makes me feel like I've become superfluous."
What she wanted was the world's number one, the very best—the one and only "eldest legitimate best friend." There were also issues involving unequal emotional and material investment, differences in the intensity of their feelings, the distinction between intense people and reserved people, and so on and so forth. But I feel this pair is the one closest to reality.
Moreover, Wen Ji'er as a person is quite complicated—perhaps her presentation is related to her work, with a lot of embellishment involved. This time it was she who invited Wang Zixuan onto the show, wanting to understand what had happened back then; yet while she seemed proactive and generous, she also kept contradictorily shrinking back at key moments.
For example, after the two met and hugged, she came back saying she had gotten goosebumps all over and needed to hide out at Xu Fei's place: "Let me hide out at your place for a bit." "At the time I thought you were very gracious, you performed well."
Yet unexpectedly this sparked another battle: "Are you saying I wasn't gracious enough?" "Oh, is that what you mean?" "No, no, no!"—wait, you two haven't seen each other in years, and your very first exchange is this confrontational?
This was when it was mentioned that Xu Fei and Zhang Meng had crossed paths on Sisters Who Make Waves, and Ma Tianyu said "back when you two didn't tear into each other"—I feel like you two would want to tear into each other a little. "Who would I tear into?" "Me!" "When did I ever tear into you?" "It was always him insulting me!" "When did I ever insult you?" "Never in public, but privately I insulted you plenty of times."
Wow, this is just too entertaining! You two should go jump in a river, talking like that—it feels like Ma Tianyu is really enjoying the drama. But then look who shows up: "Let me get drunk first, okay?"
But actually, the conflict between Ma Tianyu and Zhang Meng wasn't that serious, and after all, both have been in the industry for many years and are experienced in handling matters. Still, Ma Tianyu couldn't shed his sharp-tongued nature, and he wastes no words either.
The two seem to be joking and laughing, but there are actually deep cracks: in 2016, Ma Tianyu played Ying Kongshi in Ice Fantasy, and Zhang Meng played Yandan; on screen they were a tragic-romance CP, "Hagen Dan Shi," and off screen they became close friends who talked about everything, a supportive older sister and younger brother pair—even to the point of traveling together with their families, and her giving red envelopes when he had a child.
But later Zhang Meng transitioned into being a producer, running around seeking resources and recruiting people for her own productions, and naturally her good friend Ma Tianyu couldn't escape her radar. But it happened to coincide with Ma Tianyu's father being gravely ill and him being in an emotional low, so he politely declined Zhang Meng. The unaware Zhang Meng blurted out: "Fine, then don't ever come to any of my productions again."
This remark left Ma Tianyu unable to understand: "Just because I refused you? Isn't that only human? So when you come to me, am I obligated to say yes? Just because we're good friends?" He felt Zhang Meng had crossed a line, and in a fit of anger he deleted her—even his whole family deleted Zhang Meng too: "His older sister deleted me too!" "That hurt my heart."
Don't be fooled by Ma Tianyu's joking, easygoing appearance—because of his family of origin, he is actually a person with an extremely strong sense of boundaries. Qi Wei, one of his closer friends now, lives just one wall away from his home, yet he has never once been to Qi Wei's house. Perhaps also because of his family, his understanding of friendship seems to be the kind that is "free to drift apart at any time," "of no consequence"—as if there is no such thing as lasting friendship in life.
The show once released a clip of a future test, in which he said: "Life has no close friends, no family member I can confide in. I have no sense of happiness, I have no desires at all. I tried to find such a person, and I couldn't find a single one. In a state where my mood was especially bad, I went to chat with an AI."—Honestly, that's rather sad too. He is the kind of person who spends a lifetime healing himself, and even Zhang Meng somewhat regretted whether she should have invited him onto this show.
In fact, Ma Tianyu also has a farm in the countryside, which serves as his own pure land, a place to heal himself. So you can see that he and Zhang Meng, who is now being pushed along by her producer work, are completely different kinds of people.
And he feels that Zhang Meng's forceful manner triggers some of his family shadows: in his family, across three generations—his older sister, his aunt, his grandmother—were all women with an extremely strong desire for control. "But there was nothing I could do, because I'm also very afraid of this." So he also couldn't understand why Zhang Meng insisted on bringing him onto this show, as if it absolutely had to be him.
And now, when asked, Zhang Meng doesn't even know whether she and Ma Tianyu counted as friends in the past: "I want to re-establish contact and find out why we drifted apart." Fortunately, Ma Tianyu affirmed their relationship: "I'm very afraid of that friendship from ten years ago—it may not even have been friendship, it may just have been a colleague." "It doesn't count? " "Although we filmed for a year, I don't consider us to have been merely colleagues.
I felt she was like an older sister, always with that feeling of wanting to protect me—I could feel it."
He actually cares deeply about this friendship. But when the two actually met, they couldn't match up their accounts of why they broke off—there seems to have been a discrepancy in the event each of them held in their hearts as the cause of their estrangement: "The main thing I was angry about was something you said." "What did I say?" "You said, don't ever come to any of my productions again—don't ever act in my productions again." "I said something like that?" "Yes, you did." "No, it wasn't that."
But as I kept watching, I was moved by Zhang Meng during the post-dinner introductions segment: despite years of not seeing each other, Zhang Meng still remembered Ma Tianyu's preferences, and even when traveling abroad she would, as per their old habit, collect beautiful mugs for him—"Do you remember you liked collecting mugs? " "Wow, yes—I don't know if you still do now." She pulled them out of her bag one by one, just to prove that she had never forgotten him in her heart—surely no one could fail to be touched by this!
"I bought it for you before, and I'll still buy it for you." "I did buy it before, but I remember, but the two of us—but the two of us..." I'm always moved by people of action anyway. The two of them simply turned things into a grand confession scene: "I really like Xiao Ma, and I really want to cherish him, because—because when we first met, I learned some things about his family background, and I truly think he's kind, and I think he's very strong."
So what exactly caused you two to drift apart? Not just you two—I want to know the truth as well. But just as Ma Tianyu said, this beautiful relationship seems so perfect that it makes one a little suspicious: "Some of what he said was sincere, but at the same time there are some things I'm a bit doubtful about, yet at the same time some things do exist. But no matter how much of it is true and how much is false, it all needs to be faced."
On the other hand, the last pair, the esports boys Qingzhi and Bai Xiaochun, I felt were truly pure. They came here because Qingzhi clearly wanted to ease tensions and reconcile, and through the pre-recorded clip we learned that Qingzhi ultimately apologized to Bai Xiaochun: "Because of some of my immaturity before, I sincerely apologize to you here. I'm sorry."
But when they first met, Bai Xiaochun gave him no chance at all: from beginning to end he treated Qingzhi like a stranger, like he was invisible—it even felt like he came on this show just to get revenge and humiliate him. When Qingzhi helped carry his luggage, he felt uncomfortable all over: "It would've been fine if he hadn't helped me with my luggage, but when he came to help me carry it, I felt like he was putting on an act."
The two of them have a very youthful, passionate story: two genius boys met at a club, the twin stars won a championship together, became each other's first choice in life, did silly things, took silly photos—just like many brothers in their school days. You could even say they were inseparable and told each other everything.
But it seems a divergence arose in their views on esports: one treated esports as an ideal, the other as a job, and there were also some interests involved. In any case, Qingzhi couldn't stand many of Bai Xiaochun's "lazy behaviors," like not putting in extra practice and clocking out on time, and because they were close, he always wanted to nitpick and manage him, which eventually led to a quarrel—they even almost came to blows: "He stood up, and I stood up with him too, and then he gave me attitude, saying things in that kind of tone." "No, I was just giving him attitude."
Normally these would just be typical conflicts from school days, but their professional circumstances were different from students': Qingzhi also publicly stated in a livestream that reconciliation was impossible—"Yes, well, since it's been said, let's say it: he and I definitely cannot reconcile, that's it."
Moreover, according to Bai Xiaochun, Qingzhi even went to the company's senior management to badmouth him, saying he had character problems: "I just hate it—why would I say my character is bad?" He even believes this was one of the reasons he was kicked out by the company and left the team: "That is, saying I got booted from my previous company."
But the actual situation, we don't know. Only when the two sat down face to face did they discover that even their information about each other was somewhat mismatched: "As I remember it, I went to find XX, and it was all about telling you to work harder." But in any case, former teammates have become present rivals, even enemies—"I think he and I truly have a grudge; from my standpoint, he is my enemy." "If I said those kinds of things, then it's only right for him to hate me; if he said that about me, I would hate him too.
If I were carrying that kind of thought, I don't know how big the impact on him would be, but it would definitely be very painful."
So under these circumstances, Qingzhi has actually always wanted to get closer to Bai Xiaochun, but Bai Xiaochun, upon their first meeting, was frantically avoiding him and holding grudges. Especially on the night they moved in, when everyone had to split up rooms, the awkwardness peaked: everyone did everything they could to avoid sharing a room with their former CP—Wen Ji'er chose Xu Fei: "At the time I actually didn't really want to room together; I felt it would be a bit awkward." Li Na roomed with Wang Zixuan, and Zhang Meng took a room by herself.
Only the two younger brothers were both shy and powerless to resist in front of their seniors. The plan was for the three boys to squeeze into one room, but Ma Tianyu suddenly wanted a single room, leaving the two younger brothers at a loss—Bai Xiaochun hurriedly said in alarm: "The two of us together? No way!
My Tianyu-ge, if you sleep here, what are the two of us supposed to do? It might be really awkward." In fact, Ma Tianyu's original intention was to create an opportunity for the two kids, but he never expected them to be so thin-skinned: "Are you two afraid of awkwardness? "—honestly, this show would fall apart without Ma Tianyu!
But I truly didn't expect that the most awkward pair upon first meeting would be these two: even at mealtimes, they chose the table farthest from each other, and even ladling soup required explanations, for fear others would misunderstand—anyway, he really took it that far. To show "I can't eat when I see you," Bai Xiaochun barely ate at all, and in the middle of the night hid alone eating instant noodles: "With an enemy sitting across from you, could you eat a meal?"
But the most brilliant part of this segment was actually the unconscious little gestures during the meal: like Wang Zixuan instinctively calling out an old nickname, and the other person beaming with joy yet giving no reply; Li Na and Xu Fei were like this too—at dinner, Li Na would push dishes toward Xu Fei: "Let's get something cold and drink for a while," pushing the dishes over. Ah, it made me laugh!
And through everyone's questioning, the two of them let information slip out bit by bit: "Because I remember back then you two—who wrote songs for whom?" "On the show? She never wrote a song for me." It turns out Li Na didn't even know Xu Fei had written a song for her, and Xu Fei herself was stubborn and kept it hidden: "Did you write a song for me?" "No." "No." "I have had a song written for me by her—she doesn't know!"
So wait—sisters, is it really just this little bit of surface stuff between you two? Otherwise, if things were so good before, how did they become like this? "Was it a case of who betrayed whom?" At the mention of this, the two simultaneously put down their chopsticks, both putting on cold, battle-ready faces.
Especially after the meal there was an even more intense segment—the aforementioned "introducing the other person as they exist in your heart." Li Na unleashed a killer move: "I said, after some things happened, I don't know what kind of person she is, so I cannot introduce her." Denying everything in the past, saying she doesn't know this person at all—this is pure hatred.
Meanwhile Xu Fei across from her wrote several pages at length, which almost seemed like a joke: as she read out, with trembling hands, a past as beautiful as a love letter—"She can always perfectly combine elegance and refinement in one person"... yet at the same time she felt she wasn't the other's one and only.
That's right, the two women's statements seem to be the reverse of the story in the earlier clip—it seems there's quite a lot going on here. As for the other two pairs, their content matched what I introduced earlier. Anyway, it's these four pairs: former CPs of different ages, genders, and reasons, setting out from the starting point, traveling for 18 days through Lhasa and trekking to Nyingchi.
Along the way they have to eat, sleep, and live together and untangle their knots—but they don't necessarily have to reconcile and forgive—as long as you feel it's OK, you can get off early.
What I find most brilliant about this show is its refusal to force anything: it simply breaks down the drifting apart of lives into four sets of specimens, each of a completely different type—one person is stuck on a single angry remark, another on a rumor that can't quite be pinned down, another drifted apart slowly as if nothing had happened at all, and another, while still holding onto resentment, turned their true feelings into songs and stories.
But—hey, you're allowed not to forgive. Apparently, Li Na never forgave in the end, and so what? After all, I came here for my own release. Perhaps laying out words that had been bottled up for 15 years is already the answer in itself.
What adult friendships fear most is never the falling-out itself, but losing even the chance to have a proper fight—"Can't I just come here to have it out once?" So whether there's a reunion ahead or we never meet again, at least this time, it offered a chance to try once more.