The newly launched "After We Parted as Friends" once again left me stunned. The person I thought would be talking about interests spent the whole show talking about feelings; the person I thought would be talking about feelings spent the whole show talking about money and interests. I'm talking about Wen Ji'er and Wang Zixuan, this pair of plastic besties—constantly calling each other "baby, baby, baby," yet I couldn't feel a shred of genuine affection.
Let me state my position first: I still really dislike Wen Ji'er. And Wang Zixuan? I feel a bit sorry that she got hammered so hard by Wen Ji'er on the show, but rationally I think this is a consequence she should bear for this so-called friendship. In this episode I'll give a very detailed, purely subjective personal analysis of their words and actions in the cliffside cabin, and I hope viewers can agree to disagree. Thanks, everyone.
In the cliffside cabin, Wen Ji'er kept checking his phone the moment he sat down, probably preparing evidence for the upcoming confrontation. After sitting with Wang Zixuan, Wang Zixuan's overall state was relaxed—because she had no idea she was about to face an extremely embarrassing situation. Wen Ji'er, on the other hand, knew exactly what he was going to say and what controversies might arise, so he chose to eat.
From a psychological perspective, eating before a confrontation usually expresses anxiety, a desire to steady oneself, and a performance of calmness.
When Zhang Quanling opened the envelope and Wen Ji'er read out that line, Wang Zixuan's face was full of shock: "Writing a preface, a fee of thirty thousand yuan?" "What?" She had probably never imagined that the endpoint of their broken friendship would be money. Zhang Meng, sitting beside them, was already familiar with the tug-of-war in financial disputes and quickly sensed the high pressure of this conversation: "My God, I feel like I'm about to get a lesson too."
When Wen Ji'er faced everyone alone and began recounting what happened, his gaze kept darting back and forth among the people present. From a psychological perspective, this means he was trying to use other people's expressions as a mirror to confirm whether his account could be believed, while also distributing the pressure of one-on-one eye contact with Zhang Quanling across everyone.
Wen Ji'er initially described the preface incident like this: in 2018 he was going to publish a book, and the publisher suggested he find a friend to write the preface, so he asked Wang Zixuan. "While we were out shopping and having a meal, that afternoon I said to her, I said baby, I said I'm writing a new book, I said I've finished my book, I said the publisher told me to find a friend to write the preface.
Then she asked me, she said, so who else have you asked so far? I said I had asked someone. Then she said oh okay, and then she asked me: so how much does a preface cost?
"
"Actually she never collected money, you know? Never collected money. I just made it up, I said thirty or forty thousand, something like that." "So that thirty or forty thousand—you made it up?" "Right."
In the first episode, Wang Zixuan was surprised to discover that the book also had a preface written by their mutual friend Louis, which shows she didn't know Louis would write a preface for Wen Ji'er. So the other friend whose name was bleeped out on the show must be the third person who wrote a preface—a friend who is a writer.
Then Ma Tianyu asked him why he didn't just tell Wang Zixuan that no money was charged for the preface, and his answer was that he "didn't know the going rates." "Then why didn't you just—why did you say money was charged? " "Right, because at that time I didn't understand either, I didn't understand what the rules of this circle were." Many people say Wen Ji'er was lying: because in 2014 he had already published a short story collection, with inscriptions from leaders and recommendations from writers; and his 2018 essay collection had a preface by Li Rui.
For someone with multiple book-publishing experiences to claim he didn't understand the norms around prefaces is extremely unconvincing—either he never personally handled the publishing matters from start to finish, with someone behind the scenes taking care of everything. No wonder netizens dug into his family resources and educational background; there's just no hard evidence, so I won't go further into that here.
Then he continued recalling the story of Wang Zixuan charging him for the preface. The impression his words gave was that Wang Zixuan was eagerly demanding money from him—asking Wen Ji'er to transfer the money as soon as the preface was written. To prove he wasn't making things up, Wen Ji'er proactively offered to show the transfer records to Zhang Quanling, Ma Tianyu, and Zhang Meng.
Zhang Quanling was somewhat surprised and taken aback—perhaps not by the dispute itself, but by the fact that Wen Ji'er had prepared the transfer receipts in advance, dead set on hammering someone. But what was clear was that the three of them showed not the slightest empathy or support for Wen Ji'er; in particular, Ma Tianyu and Zhang Meng kept expressing that "there should be adult dignity": "We all came here hoping to reconcile, and we still have adult dignity—adult dignity means not giving the other person any humiliating way out; what adults need most is to preserve their own dignity."
Babes, besides friendship needing dignity, our bodies need dignity too. Especially for my big-chested sisters like me—don't you always feel that finding the right bra is just like meeting the right friend? Well, sisters watching this video today can relax, because I'm recommending two bras that perfectly solved my dressing worries: Naitangpai's Weitian 3.0 and XianDiao 4.0.
Weitian 3.0 is Naitangpai's make-big-chests-look-smaller bra. It doesn't rely on squeezing; it relies on the aesthetics of light and shadow: three-dimensional tailoring plus principles of light and shadow, gathering upward and inward while contouring the chest—the highlight zone diminishes the sense of bulge, visually making you look one to two cup sizes smaller, and you look slim in whatever you wear.
It also features custom soft underwires based on breast shape: smaller busts use memory soft underwire that doesn't poke the sternum, larger busts use reinforced soft underwire for steady support; the "bunny ear" cups come in a foundation-skin tone, thin to just one millimeter—whether I wear light-colored shirts or tight T-shirts, the cup pads are invisible, and I finally don't have to agonize in front of the mirror over whether an outfit can be worn out.
As for XianDiao 4.0, it's even more amazing: a wireless bra made exclusively for big chests—the words "wireless" are something big-chested sisters know all too well how mystical they are: comfortable, yes truly comfortable, but prone to sagging. But XianDiao 4.0 goes straight to black technology: figure-eight encircling jelly strips provide 360-degree lifting, like a pair of hands constantly holding you up against gravity; inward-tightening small bands pull armpit fat inward, making you look super slim in tank tops and camisoles; and at the bottom there's a reinforced W-shaped simulated underwire—you get the comfort of wireless plus wire-like support, missing neither.
The fabric uses 7D ultra-fine yarn, finer than a strand of hair, feeling like a second layer of skin on your body; honeycomb-hole cup pads plus hollowed-out little windows plus sweat-wicking at the cup back mean no stuffy chest even wearing it all day in summer; it's also a fixed cup pad, so no adjusting needed after machine washing. Sisters who like them can click the link in the comments section to order.
Let's get back to "After We Parted as Friends."
Wen Ji'er paid no heed whatsoever to dignity and kept going. His grievance was this: other friends said a preface shouldn't cost money, so Wang Zixuan taking his money was equivalent to not treating Wen Ji'er as a friend. "Why do I keep dwelling on this—" saying that none of us ever said we'd charge friends for writing prefaces.
"A friend told me, he said you can't charge that price, because I was just starting out back then. Later I asked around through a friend, and, oh, his preface was actually quite expensive at the time."
In this conversation, Wen Ji'er seems to be working hard to project the image of an innocent, naive victim, repeatedly borrowing the words of third-party friends to pass judgment on Wang Zixuan for lacking loyalty between friends. But Zhang Quanling refused to follow his script and directly pierced the key fork in the story: did you actively go ask others whether writing a preface should be paid for, and actively tell outsiders that Wang Zixuan charged you money?
Or did someone else bring it up by chance, and only then did you belatedly feel you had been taken advantage of?
"So you asked someone else first—that is, 'Zixuan charged me money for writing my preface'—did you ask people outside about this?" "Yes, I did." "Under what circumstances did you ask, and whom did you ask?" "It's hard for me to suddenly tell a friend that they wrote a preface and got paid for it."
The difference between these two scenarios is huge. If he himself felt uncomfortable and went around asking whether a friend should be charged for writing a preface, then he wouldn't be able to win the audience's sympathy—many people would think he brought it on himself: since the writer friend didn't charge, why did he slap his own face to look generous and claim he paid?
And once he said he would pay, what was wrong with Wang Zixuan quoting a price? Moreover, if Wang Zixuan's charging really made him uncomfortable, he could have raised it directly at the time, instead of running off to complain about Wang Zixuan to others seeking validation, and now coming on the show to put her on trial—it makes him look like he wants to have it both ways.
But if he paid Wang Zixuan 30,000 yuan without knowing the norms at all, and only later, in casual conversation, learned that friends don't charge for writing prefaces—then he missed the chance to refuse payment to Wang Zixuan at the time, which is the only way his current anger and years of resentment could become reasonable.
He clearly understood the point of Zhang Quanling's challenge, so he immediately rolled up his sleeves, quickly interrupted Zhang Quanling, sped up his speech, and began describing in detail how the topic came up in conversation. This behavior is a classic outwardly expressive stress posture: large, slightly exaggerated movements, combined with a tight voice or accelerated speech, indicating that his current state is nervous but forcing himself to hold up.
"I said I was breaking even, I said, mm, I said I was still in a state where I wasn't really making money. He said, how could that be? He said you should have savings. I said it's because I paid for my preface. He said, you paid for a preface? He said, who did you pay? So I told him." "Was the person who said this from the entertainment industry or the publishing world?" "Someone from the entertainment industry." "And then he said—and then he asked me directly, he said, does he really treat you as a friend?"
After Wen Ji'er finished describing the process, it seemed detailed and plausible, but Zhang Quanling didn't follow his logic; instead, she asked a question about timing: "Was this the first time this thorn lodged itself in your heart?" "Yes." "What year was that?" "2019." Wen Ji'er was momentarily stunned by this question, perhaps not understanding what it signified, so he nervously licked his lips, then looked upward to think, and finally came up with the answer "2019."
It was precisely from this point that his account began to show obvious contradictions. When I first watched it, I didn't understand why Zhang Quanling asked this question, but by the end I realized how brilliant this line of questioning was: Zhang Quanling apparently doubted the truthfulness of Wen Ji'er's account of the past, so she decided to disrupt his prearranged narrative logic, to avoid being led around by him.
That's why Zhang Quanling's questions all seemed unrelated—they not only confused me as a viewer, but also confused Wen Ji'er.
Zhang Quanling first asked: "Were you still in contact in 2019?" Wen Ji'er answered firmly: "In 2019, you were still in contact, right? In 2019, when someone from the entertainment industry told you that in the industry, prefaces probably aren't paid for, and at that time you didn't ask him face to face to pull out this thorn in your heart, the reason was—" "I didn't want to ask." "What were you afraid of?" "I didn't want to ask." "What was the reason you didn't want to ask?" "I didn't want to face it."
Zhang Quanling immediately pressed on: "When you went around asking others about whether prefaces should be paid for, were you already feeling uncomfortable inside?" Wen Ji'er, dazed, answered in the affirmative: "When you went to ask others, did it mean you were already uncomfortable inside? You just wanted to know the answer to this question." "Yes."
Here's the key point: this answer contradicts the earlier claim that "at a dinner, a friend brought it up on their own, and only after that conversation did he feel uncomfortable." Compared with a polished, complete story, a person's off-the-cuff reaction when caught off guard by a sudden question is often closer to the truth. The truth is very likely that the moment Wang Zixuan named a price, Wen Ji'er already felt deeply uncomfortable.
This detail directly undermines the foundation of his persona: if he was uncomfortable the moment the money was charged, then the claim "a friend told me prefaces shouldn't be paid for, and only then did I feel wronged" loses much of its credibility—it looks more like he actively went around complaining, guided others into sympathizing with him, and then took their judgments back to pin the label of "lacking loyalty between friends" on Wang Zixuan. But if he only felt uncomfortable after talking with friends, then he would appear to be a simple little fool who was cheated out of money by a friend.
The difference between these two is a crucial point for the image he ultimately wants to project.
Then people asked him: if he was uncomfortable, why didn't he just take it up with Wang Zixuan directly? He then overturned his earlier answer to Zhang Quanling that "they were still in contact in 2019," saying that by then they had already stopped contacting each other. "Right, right, so why didn't you just tell him directly?
" "Because by that time we were no longer in contact." This completely proves as well: he wasn't uncomfortable only after talking with friends—he was already uncomfortable before that conversation.
As for him, perhaps pride and vanity were at work: he had already said he would pay the writer's fee for the preface, so he couldn't very well back out once Wang Zixuan quoted a price, and so he reluctantly transferred the money—and he did it in three separate transfers. Was he financially strapped, or was he testing whether Wang Zixuan would waive the fee for the later two payments? That's impossible to know.
But what I'm very certain of is that Wen Ji'er's resentment toward Wang Zixuan, both before and now, runs very deep, because every sentence he utters is an attack on her.
Finally, Zhang Quanling asked one more question, trying to determine whether, in Wen Ji'er's mind, Wang Zixuan's charging money carried any friendship in it: "Suppose this hypothesis: she thought, since others charge too, we should charge as well—but I'll charge half, I'll charge you a little less, as a gesture of goodwill between us." "The problem now is that I'm not sure whether what I paid her at the time was 30,000 or 40,000—I don't remember that in my head." "So that means it's also possible she charged exactly the price you yourself quoted." "Yes."
Earlier, the "30,000 to 40,000" figure was something Wen Ji'er himself admitted he had made up, but now, upon hearing Zhang Quanling seemingly speaking up for Wang Zixuan—suggesting her quote was a friendly price—Wen Ji'er became displeased again and immediately asserted that the amount Wang Zixuan charged was exactly the price he had quoted.
How should I put it—this is perhaps why audiences have such a negative impression of Wen Jier: he was the one who actively invited Wang Zixuan onto the show, and everyone assumed the guests had come hoping to get some closure on this friendship, or even to reconcile. But no one expected that he had prepared evidence, one piece after another, to nail Wang Zixuan down completely. "I had no idea what was happening—I was just abandoned." And Wang Zixuan had known nothing about any of this beforehand.
Looking back at their earlier interactions, his attitude was extremely inconsistent: one moment he would ask Wang Zixuan if she wanted a hug, and the next he would say he wanted to room with Xu Fei; in the car he sweetly called her "baby" and asked her to help touch up his makeup, then a little later he would throw out a pointed question, challenging her about the man she had introduced to him being unreliable. "Back then you also introduced a friend to me, and later I deleted him—he kept messaging me and calling me all the time." "Did you send him some kind of signal?
If you didn't want him doing that, how could there not be one? " "Because he was pretty normal—hint: he got to know me through you back then; it was when you added him on my birthday." "I didn't add him proactively—I want to emphasize, I did not add him proactively. It was on your birthday that he came over and added me on WeChat." "What was your relationship with him?
You two were close? And then you wanted us to meet, so I added him on WeChat. And then, he got in touch with me, and at the time he wanted to sign with a company, and by then I had already gone out on my own, working independently and so on, but it seems he later left the industry—" "No, no, listen to me, let me finish the story.
So at the time he told me, he said, 'Sis, I want to act; can you help recommend me for roles? ' Then one day I really did recommend him for a production, and I said, go meet the producer. That very afternoon I set up a meeting for him with the director and the producer, and told him to be somewhere at 2:30 in the afternoon.
But at 2:30 that afternoon, he couldn't be reached. I spent the whole afternoon looking for him, you know? Then he finally called me back and said, 'I had something to do this afternoon; I went to help a classmate with something or other.' I said, you went to help a classmate?
Shouldn't you have told me first? " "Did he ask you to do all of that for him? " "Of course—I have the chat records.
But I knew none of this at all. Everything between you two, I knew nothing about." "Right, that's exactly what I'm telling you—why I stopped contacting any of your friends." "But this is about you two, okay? I don't think you can just lie through your teeth."
Honestly, Wang Zixuan's answer did draw quite a lot of criticism from viewers, who felt that as a friend she didn't stand by Wen Jier, and instead questioned whether Wen Jier had given off misleading signals—so some felt Wen Jier's later anger was understandable, and they piled on Wang Zixuan. But in my view, I side with Wang Zixuan on this one: I think it was Wen Jier who showed aggression first—knowing full well the cameras were rolling, he still brought up this topic, trying to steer the audience toward the idea that "Wang Zixuan introduced him an unreliable friend." If Wang Zixuan had gone along with his words and criticized the man, it would have been unfair to a man who wasn't even present.
It's just that Wang Zixuan's reply lacked a bit of emotional intelligence and tact, and carried some of her own simmering resentment, saying things that upset Wen Jier.
When they went hiking to the cliff house, Wen Jier very amiably said he had prepared a gift for Wang Zixuan, but once inside the house his aggression was maxed out, as if he wanted to nail her to a pillar of shame; then, after leaving the house, he acted as if nothing had happened, complaining about why Wang Zixuan hadn't waited for him. The unsettling whiplash of Wen Jier's back-and-forth behavior gives me chills when I think about it—having a friend like this is dangerous: when things are good, it's "baby, baby, baby," but the moment a rift appears, they seize the chance to publicly settle scores and destroy the other person's reputation.
Although I'm criticizing Wen Jier now, that doesn't mean I'm fully on Wang Zixuan's side either. In my view, the two of them really had no business being on this show—they can hardly be called friends at all, just playmates whose relationship heated up rapidly over a few months, a plastic, superficial pairing: Wen Jier wanted Wang Zixuan's fame and emotional value, while Wang Zixuan wanted Wen Jier's financial value, both of them puffing themselves up beyond their means.
Once they discovered the other couldn't meet their expectations, the relationship collapsed instantly.
Now let's look at Wang Zixuan's conversation in the house. Zhang Quanling asked her to recount this episode from the past, and she kept raising her hand to smooth her hair to soothe her anxiety, her eyes darting around, unable to hold a steady gaze: "Honestly, really, I genuinely can't quite remember—when I saw it I was a bit surprised, and because I really can't quite remember this, I was a bit dazed."
Wang Zixuan was present when Wen Jier mentioned this lingering grievance, and afterward, while Wen Jier gave his interview, Wang Zixuan also had quite a long stretch alone, with plenty of time to process and recall. Yet when questioned, she still insisted she didn't remember the 30,000-yuan transfer—which is an obvious lie.
Many people online say things like: it's normal not to remember something from eight years ago, or that Wang Zixuan was a celebrity back then with big expenses, so 30,000 yuan was pocket change to her. None of these arguments hold up with me—besides, Wang Zixuan later admitted that she was in a very tight financial situation at that time.
It's not that Wang Zixuan doesn't remember—it's that she doesn't dare face it: she didn't know how Wen Jier would describe the whole affair when she wasn't present, so she worried about the cameras and about public judgment, and could only choose to avoid it—when recalling the past, she deliberately steered around the money, talking only about details of their interactions that had nothing to do with money. It wasn't until Zhang Quanling asked her point-blank whether she had received the transfer that Wang Zixuan, knowing deep down that she had taken the money but not daring to admit it, still said she didn't remember.
But her tense fingers and panicked micro-expressions betrayed her completely.
Ma Tianyu and Zhang Meng, having witnessed Wen Jier's poised and ready offensive, did not side with Wen Jier; the looks they gave Wang Zixuan were more of helplessness, as if to say she didn't need to lie. Wang Zixuan isn't very good at lying anyway, so although her later words didn't directly address the 30,000 yuan, they were in fact indirectly responding to her dynamic with Wen Jier, and to the pressure and vanity she felt within it: "After becoming friends with Ji'er, I felt a lot of pressure—I was very worried that I couldn't contribute anything myself." "When you two went out to play, did you split the bill, or did she mostly pay?
" "She probably paid more, but I tried, within my means, to pay a bit more of the money." "So being with her, did you feel financial pressure from receiving her favors? " "Yes, it was a bit difficult."
Short on money and having just landed a leading female role, Wang Zixuan felt she finally had the leverage to quote a commercial price. On top of that, Wen Ji'er had brought up herself that writing a preface could be paid for, which gave Wang Zixuan a psychological out, allowing her to comfortably define the whole thing as a business deal.
She convinced herself: as an artist, endorsing and promoting someone was inherently an exchange of value. What she never anticipated was that years later, Wen Ji'er would treat this transaction as hard proof of a betrayal of friendship.
She was afraid that the guests on site, and viewers after the show aired, would judge that "charging 30,000 yuan to write a preface for a friend is too mercenary." To maintain her image, she could only play dumb and dodge throughout.
"For you at the time, this wasn't a small amount of money, so you have absolutely no memory of it?" "No, it's—well, in 2018 I was too young, so maybe I didn't... but I really don't remember this." "Really?" Help.
Zhang Quanling apparently sensed the pressure she was under, and switched to hypothetical questions that lifted part of her psychological burden, allowing Wang Zixuan to gradually relax: "Suppose you did accept the money, suppose this did happen—how would you feel right now?" "A little sad—the subtext of being sad is: I thought we... I feel like I feel guilty about this, I feel guilty. If it were true, I might... I don't remember."
Afterward, Zhang Quanling apparently sensed the financial pressure Wang Zixuan was under in this relationship, and asked about the ratio of emotional value each contributed—a question that really did win Wang Zixuan back some goodwill. "In terms of emotional investment, of heartfelt investment, on a scale of ten, what's the split between you two?
" "Sixty-forty—I think, for this, I'd say I gave a bit more." Wang Zixuan said she carried most of the emotional value, a claim I'm willing to believe: in this relationship, Wen Ji'er consistently carried an implicit air of superiority—when altitude sickness made her unwell, it was Wang Zixuan who ran around taking care of her; Wen Ji'er calmly accepted others' giving and accommodation.
There's an underlying logic hidden in this dynamic: I pay money, so I'm entitled to companionship, care, and emotional concessions. People like this are usually self-assertive and domineering, and unless they possess extraordinary personal charm, it's hard for them to be accepted by others for long.
So when Zhang Quanling called her back to the cabin and told her that Wang Zixuan couldn't remember the money and would feel guilty, Wen Ji'er showed no tenderness or empathy for Wang Zixuan. Her reaction was more along the lines of "Wang Zixuan won't admit it, but I'm determined to expose her."
"Now Zixuan says her memory is a bit fuzzy, she can't recall the details of this matter. Do you want her to remember?" "I do." "Zixuan says that if this really did happen, she might feel very guilty. You still want to tell her all the evidence, the full facts, right?" "Of course."
With both of them present, Zhang Quanling tried to sort things out again and once more brought up the matter of the quoted price—and another dramatic moment occurred: Wen Ji'er once again overturned her previous account. Earlier she had admitted that "thirty to forty thousand" was a number she had made up, that she didn't understand the market rate; now she changed her story, saying she had consulted a writer friend ("brother") about the going rate: "You offered a price you basically came up with off the top of your head—" "I didn't just make it up!
Where did the thirty to forty thousand come from? It's because I had previously asked my brother about his commercial rates. But when he was helping me with this before, he told me clearly: he wouldn't charge."
All right, if that statement is true, the story might go like this: she had looked up the industry rates in advance, but the writer friend agreed to write her preface for free, so she assumed her best friend Wang Zixuan should also help for free. But Wang Zixuan didn't write it for free as she expected—instead she quoted a price, putting Wen Ji'er in a dilemma.
The money was reluctantly paid out, and resentment took root. Wen Ji'er began complaining to others, deepening her sense of grievance amid her friends' echoes, then coldly blocked Wang Zixuan.
But none of this was enough to dissolve the knot in her heart, so she took the initiative to invite Wang Zixuan onto the variety show, originally intending to prove before the cameras, to everyone, that Wang Zixuan wasn't worthy of being her friend.
But her plan fell through: viewers didn't unanimously rally to her side, and the other guests kept giving Wang Zixuan ways to save face. This outcome will probably only make Wen Ji'er feel even more aggrieved.
"I'm also an artist, I can empathize with you, I can feel what you feel: if you were a writer and you asked me to write a preface, from my perspective, inside and out, I'd consider it a commercial transaction—I'm your good friend, I have a certain level of fame, and she's using your fame to make money, to write these things. Since she's making money, I'd want to make some money too, which is perfectly understandable—everyone wants to make money.
Whether to charge is a choice; some people choose to charge, some choose not to, and I think both are fine."
Whether guests or viewers, everyone instinctively prefers an open, dignified way of handling things. Wen Ji'er's repeatedly contradictory testimony, her style of deliberately hiding her edge and then suddenly turning hostile, her manner of speaking sweetly one moment and then pulling out evidence to settle scores the next—it's hard not to see her as hypocritical and to want to keep one's distance from her.
All right, that's everything for this episode. My commentary on the guests of "Reunion with Friends" is purely my subjective opinion—let's agree to disagree. I'm Lili Lili Lizi Jie. If you enjoyed this, please like, coin, and favorite, and follow—see you in the next episode!